Best Car Insurance Companies for March 2024

 Company Price Purchasing Options Available Discounts Other Available Coverage
State Farm Best Overall $2,089 Local agent, phone, online 10 Home, renters, life, health, pet, disability, liability, small business
Erie Insurance Best Cheap Car Insurance and Best for Drivers Under 25 $1,621 Online, phone, local agent 8 Motorcycle, RV, marine, renters, flood, personal valuables, life, umbrella, business, identity theft
Sentry Best with a DUI $4,392 Local agent 7 Commercial auto insurance, dealership auto coverage, motor carrier coverage, physical damage insurance, non-trucking liability insurance
New Jersey Manufacturers (NJM) Group Best for High-Risk Drivers $1,694 Phone, local agent 12 Liability, comprehensive, collision, underinsured/uninsured, medical expenses, classic and collector car, motorcycle and ATV, boat and personal watercraft
Progressive Best for Multiple Vehicles and Best for Bundling with Home and Other Policies $2,430 Online, phone 13 AT/RV, marine, classic car, golf cart, flood, homeowners, mobile home, renters, travel, umbrella, pet, wedding, personal
USAA Best for Military Families $1,471 Online, phone, agent 10 Motorcycle, ATV/RV, classic car, marine, aviation, renters, landlord, umbrella, flood, farm, mobile phone, life, health, business
Allstate Best for Discounts $2,641 Online, phone, local agent 14 Homeowners, renters, motorcycle, marine, classic car, RV/ATV, business, life, pet, identity theft, tuition
Auto-Owners Best for Safe Drivers $1,785 Local agent 13 Bodily injury liability, collision, comprehensive, property damage liability, medical payments, uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage

Guide for Choosing the Best Car Insurance Companies

Types of Car Insurance

The first step in figuring out the right insurance policy for you is understanding what type of auto insurance you need. An automobile insurance policy is typically a bundle of several types of coverage. Here are the most common kinds, with explanations below of each type:

  • Liability
  • Medical Payments (MedPay) or Personal Injury Protection Insurance (PIP)
  • Collision
  • Comprehensive
  • Underinsured/Uninsured Motorist

Liability Insurance

Almost every state requires liability insurance, which covers other people for damage from an accident when you’re deemed at fault. There are two types of liability insurance:

Bodily injury liability (BI): This pays for someone else’s medical expenses and lost wages if you injure them in an accident you cause. State law may determine the minimum amount you’re required to have. For example, California requires $15,000 of coverage per person, $30,000 per accident. In Texas, those minimums are doubled: $30,000 per person and $60,000 per accident.

Property damage liability: This covers the cost of repairing or replacing the other driver’s car or property, such as a fence. Property damage liability coverage is required in all states, including New Hampshire, which doesn’t require car insurance but does require this coverage if you do buy car insurance.

Medical Payments (MedPay) or Personal Injury Protection Insurance (PIP)

Medical payments coverage pays for medical expenses if you or anyone in your car are injured in an accident, no matter whose fault it is. It also covers any pedestrians you may injure and it covers you if you’re a passenger in another car or are hurt by a vehicle when you’re walking, riding a bike, or on public transportation. It is supplemental to your health insurance and is optional in most states.

Personal injury protection, also known as no-fault insurance, is similar in that it also covers you and your passengers for injuries, regardless of who’s at fault in an accident. But PIP often has higher coverage limits and insures a wider range of issues, such as psychiatric and rehabilitative care, plus lost wages, which MedPay does not. PIP is mandatory in 12 states—Florida, Hawaii, Kansas, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey, New York, North Dakota, Pennsylvania, and Utah—plus Puerto Rico, according to the Insurance Information Institute.56

Collision Coverage

Collision coverage pays for damage to your own vehicle or property in a collision with another vehicle or a stationary object, such as a tree or fence. This applies to accidents that are deemed your fault. Your state may not require it, but a lender may if you’re taking out a loan for your vehicle.

Comprehensive Coverage

Comprehensive insurance pays for loss, theft, or damage from a cause other than a collision with another car, such as a fire, hail, or theft. Your state or lender may require this coverage.

Underinsured/Uninsured Motorist Coverage

Underinsured motorist coverage can pay for your medical bills or vehicle repairs if you’re in an accident where the driver who’s at fault doesn’t have enough insurance. Uninsured motorist coverage applies if the other driver doesn’t have any insurance. Requirements for these coverages vary by state.

How to Compare Car Insurance Companies

It’s important to consider several factors to find the best car insurance for your needs.

  • Pricing: If you have a specific budget for car insurance, compare quotes from multiple providers to find coverage that aligns with your budget—but be sure you’re comparing apples-to-apples where coverage is concerned.  
  • Discounts: Most auto insurance companies offer various discounts for safe drivers, college students, or military members. 
  • Coverage types: Most insurance companies cover the basic comprehensive and collision coverage, but other, specialized coverages may not be so commonly found, such as electric or classic automobile insurance.
  • Policy limit: Each type of coverage comes with a maximum limit that shows exactly how much of your losses will be covered by your insurance company. Some companies may offer more coverage than others, which becomes important when you drive a luxury or classic car.
  • Company ratings: Certain industry ratings can help determine what kind of experience you’ll have with an insurer. Consider auto insurance ratings like J.D. Power for customer satisfaction and AM Best for financial stability. 
  • Your credit history: In some states, insurers can change your rate depending on whether you have poor credit history. Drivers with poor credit may need to shop around a bit more compared to someone with good credit.
  • Availability: Before you buy a policy, you need to be sure that the insurance company you choose will service your area. Some companies like Sentry are only available in a handful of states.  

How Much Does Car Insurance Cost?

According to The Zebra, the average cost of car insurance nationwide is $880 for a six-month policy, or $147 a month. But your costs will vary significantly based on your location, age, vehicle, driving record, and the amount of coverage you choose.

Car Insurance Rates by State

Most states have minimum liability insurance requirements at the least. The table below shows the average six-month premiums for minimum liability coverage, as well as full coverage, defined by 50/100/50 liability limits, plus collision and comprehensive coverage with $500 deductibles each.

Average 6-Month Premium by State – Minimum Liability Coverage vs. Full Coverage
State State Min. Liability Full Coverage
Alabama $272 $886
Alaska $243 $925
Arizona $306 $876
Arkansas $310 $1,059
California $305 $966
Colorado $282 $1,090
Connecticut $451 $981
Delaware $460 $1,059
Florida $413 $1,462
Georgia $370 $991
Hawaii $231 $704
Idaho $183 $599
Illinois $257 $758
Indiana $203 $633
Iowa $136 $679
Kansas $239 $895
Kentucky $461 $1,284
Louisiana $463 $1,351
Maine $211 $620
Maryland $457 $1,009
Massachusetts $230 $709
Michigan $452 $1,088
Minnesota $296 $853
Mississippi $271 $907
Missouri $298 $959
Montana $184 $899
Nebraska $198 $909
Nevada $426 $1,114
New Hampshire $208 $641
New Jersey $473 $1,022
New Mexico $224 $814
New York $491 $1,086
North Carolina $229 $574
North Dakota $198 $778
Ohio $192 $590
Oklahoma $232 $949
Oregon $353 $755
Pennsylvania $252 $889
Rhode Island $466 $1,164
South Carolina $367 $1,012
South Dakota $133 $804
Tennessee $225 $759
Texas $366 $993
Utah $329 $809
Vermont $166 $592
Virginia $299 $757
Washington $395 $910
Washington, D.C. $400 $1,106
West Virginia $260 $855
Wisconsin $199 $691
Wyoming $156 $794

Car Insurance Rates by Age

Your age can have a major impact on the price of your car insurance. Teens in particular pay a premium because data shows that younger drivers are on average riskier. Rates go down as you get older, until you’re in your 60s and 70s, when they start rising again. To get cheaper insurance at any age, it’s very important to shop around and get quotes from at least three companies.

Average 6-Month and 1-Month Premiums by Age Group
Age Group Avg. 6 Month Premium Avg. Monthly Premium
16-19 $2,670 $445
20s $1,142 $190
30s $872 $145
40s $834 $139
50s $777 $130
60s $785 $131
70s $903 $151

How to Find the Best Price on Car Insurance

There are several steps you can take to save on car insurance and find the cheapest policy for you.

1. Shop around: This is the most important step. Get quotes from major national automobile insurance companies as well as local providers. If you want help from an agent, choose an independent insurance agent that represents numerous companies.

2. Think how much liability coverage you need: Your state may have minimum liability limits. But also consider the value of your home, savings, and other assets. Your liability limits should be at least as much as their value. Otherwise, the assets may be at risk if you cause an accident whose damages exceed your coverage limits.

3. Choose a higher deductible: You may be able to lower your monthly premium but increasing your deductible. But keep in mind that a high deductible will require you to pay more later if you need to make a claim.

4. Skip comprehensive and collision coverage: Although most lenders require these coverages, if you don’t have a car loan, you may be able to get away without them—especially if you have an older car. Compare your car’s book value to the deductible and premiums for comprehensive and collision. Kelley Blue Book and Edmunds are two sites that can help you determine your car’s book value.

5. Ask about car insurance discounts: Some insurers offer discounts for bundling multiple kinds of policies (such as homeowners or renters), putting other family members on the policy, having a clean driving record, owning certain safety and antitheft equipment, or being a good student. You may also get a discount for paying your annual premium all at once or enrolling in electronic billing.

6. Consider usage-based insurance: Black-box insurance, also known as pay-as-you-go insurance, uses a telematics device installed in your car that tracks your mileage, when you drive, and how well you drive. Allstate’s Drivewise is one such program. Allstate says Drivewise can only lower your premium. The company will not raise your premium based on your driving behavior.

Car Insurance News

U.S. drivers seem resigned to higher car insurance premiums. Prices went up more than 20% in 2023, according to data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. That’s the biggest annual jump since 1976. Premium increases are partly due to the rising cost of cars, as well as increased repair costs due to more expensive technology in today’s cars.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Does Car Insurance Work?

In return for you paying insurance premiums, an auto insurance policy protects you against personal and financial costs if you’re involved in a car accident. It can also pay for damage to your car stemming from natural causes, such as a flood or fire. If you’re in such a situation, the insurer may pay for damages directly after you file a claim, or it may require you to pay out of pocket and then submit a claim for reimbursement.

What Is a Car Insurance Premium?

A car insurance premium is the amount you pay for your policy. You usually pay this either every month, every six months, or annually. Premiums are determined by a number of factors, including your location, age, driving record, vehicle, coverage, deductible, and your credit record.

Do I Need Car Insurance?

Yes, in nearly all cases. At the very least, most U.S. states require that drivers meet minimum car insurance requirements to legally operate a vehicle. Car insurance can help protect you if you collide with another vehicle or object. Any damages your vehicle sustains will be your responsibility unless you have insurance to cover your losses. Certain types of auto insurance can also cover legal fees and medical bills for yourself, your passengers, and the other vehicle’s passengers. 

What Does Car Insurance Cover?

Basic car insurance covers damage to other vehicles or property if you’re responsible for an accident. It can also cover injury-related medical bills and legal fees arising after a collision. You can choose to add more coverage to protect your own car from accidents where you’re at fault, or from a hit-and-run driver. Further optional coverage could help pay for your accident-related medical bills or bills of your passengers.

What Factors Affect the Cost of Car Insurance?

Insurers use several factors to price your auto insurance premiums, including age, gender, and credit score. Insurers will look up your driving record using your driver’s license number to determine whether you’re a risk-taking driver. During the car insurance quote process, you’ll provide your vehicle identification number (VIN), as your auto’s age, accident history, and safety features can influence costs, too. Certain drivers, such as students, seniors, or military members, may be eligible for extra savings that can help lower the cost of car insurance.

What Insurance Is Best for Adults With Teen Drivers?

According to our research, State Farm is the best car insurance company for teens because it offers a broad array of coverage and a couple of good discount options. Its Steer Clear program offers a discount if you’re under 25 and don’t have any moving violations or at-fault accidents on your record. And its Drive Safe & Save program allows you to save up to 30% on your premiums for driving safely.

That said, we found that Progressive has the cheapest insurance for an adult policy with a teen added.

What is the Largest Auto Insurer in the U.S.?

The largest auto insurer in the U.S. is State Farm. According to Investopedia research on the biggest insurance companies, State Farm offers the largest dollar amount of property and casualty insurance policies in the U.S.

Companies We Reviewed

We researched and reviewed 25 companies to find the best eight companies you see above on this list. Below are the companies we researched. Those that didn’t make our list may have had higher prices, lower customer experience ratings, or less nationwide availability.

USAA, Erie, Country Insurance, Auto-Owners, Southern Farm Bureau, State Farm, New Jersey Manufacturers Insurance, Geico, American Family, Nationwide, Progressive, The Hartford (AARP), Travelers, Shelter, Alfa, Allstate, Farmers, Kemper, Auto Club Group (AAA) Michigan, Amica, CSAA Insurance Group (AAA), Mercury, Sentry, Automobile Club Group, The Hanover.


Our team evaluated 25 insurance companies and collected thousands of data points before selecting our top choices. We weighed eight criteria and gave a higher weight to those with a more significant impact on potential customers. 

The factors we most heavily considered when scoring insurers include median annual premium (weighted 25%), fairness in pricing methodology (weighted 15%), and regional availability (weighted 15%). We also took into account other features that are important to buyers including complaint scores, consumer satisfaction reports from J.D. Power and Consumer Reports, and company loss ratios.

For further information about our selection criteria and process, see our complete methodology.

About admin

Check Also

What Is an Auto Insurance Quote?

An auto insurance quote is an estimate of the amount you will pay for a …

Deja una respuesta

Tu dirección de correo electrónico no será publicada. Los campos obligatorios están marcados con *

Recent Comments

No hay comentarios que mostrar.